High Fat Diet Causes Cancer? Not so fast...
First, the headlines. Science Daily, a generally reliable source of info for folks like me, reported this: "Excessive Dietary Fat Caused 300 Percent Increase in Metastasizing Tumor Cells in Animal Models".
Now- tell the truth- what immediately came to mind when you read that?
Let me guess: "Another study "confirming" how bad saturated fat is, and how low-fat eating can help prevent cancer".
Wrong, grasshopper.
The researchers didn't even investigate saturated fat.
Here's what they did: They implanted tumor cells in mice. Then they fed one group a "high-fat" diet and the other group a "lean" diet. Then, using a number of sophisticated measuring techniques, they looked to see how the diets impacted the ability of cancer cells to metastasize (spread from one part of the body to another).
Here's what they found: Oleic acid- the kind of (monounsaturated) fat found in olive oil- had precisely no effect on the spreading of the cancer. Linoleic acid, however, had a big effect- the rate of metastasis rose a dramatic 300 percent!
Linoleic acid is Omega-6: it's the fat found in all those vegetable oils that everyone tells you are so good for you. Corn oil, safflower oil, sunflower oil, etc.
This information was buried in the 15th paragraph (of a 19 paragraph article).
There's been mounting evidence that overconsumption of omega-6 fats may not be such a great thing. I've been saying for a long time that the balance between omega 6 and omega 3 fats in the diet is an extremely important one for human health. The ideal ratio is between 1:1 and 4:1. More typically, those consuming a Western diet get between 15:1 and 25:1.
You can shift this balance to a more healthy one by cutting back on high omega-6 vegetable oils (which are generally inferior to begin with) and increasing your intake of omega 3's.
You shouldn't cut omega-6's out of your diet completely- they're good for you in the right amounts. Be sure to get a high quality omega-6, like GLA found in evening primrose oil, and stay away from the commercial processed vegetable oils.
![]() | Save 10%: When you order this special EPA/DHA + GLA bundle (normally $52.94) for just $47.65 |
Labels: bad fats, cancer, evening primrose oil, fat, omega-3, omega-3 fats, omega-3s, omega-6, saturated, study




Thanks for debunking this Jonny!
It would be nice if someone could produce a simple document outlining good health study reporting. Possibly in the form of a flowchart, with basic questions to ask. And then send it to all reporters, esp. "science" based ones, lol. In this case they have over generalized. A classic mistake. Other mistakes are often with percentages - yes it's a 300% increase - but from what in the first place. Does this even matter?
E.g. 300% increase in chance of dieing sound horrible. But if that was a 1 in 3 million chance it is not that bad..
Trouble is that some people whose metabolic type suits high fat will now be avoiding it!
In fact the myth that saturated fats are causing CVD (cardiovascular disease)is another one that still is held as truth by most Mds.
A good article on this (by M Enig) was posted on Dr. Mercola's site.
Here is the link:
http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2002/08/21/saturated-fat2.aspx.
Also,I know Dr Peskin (see Peskin protocole)shows a ratio of 1:1 to 4:1 (I think) omega6/3 is ideal for cancer prevention and treatment, as well as arteriosclerosis prev + treatmt.
This field is so full of lies and poorly written studies.
Cindy Krueger (MPH) says " a scant 17-20% of conventional medical practices are based on scientifically validated evidence, the rest are based on anecdotal data" (based on US Congress office of techn assessment 1988 - a little old but how much has changed?)
Chris
Jonny,
I take at least 1-3 tablespoons of flaxseed oil plus 1 teaspoon of quality fish oil daily, have eliminated commmercial vegetable oils as much as possible and use olive, coconut and ghee instead. Could I still get too much Omega 6 from overconsumption of flaxseed and the other "good" oils?
Thanks, Debbie
hi- very very unlikely! You are not the intended audience for this message- you're doing fine!
warmly
jb
Wow... Great article!! http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/63544.php
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home